Beyond Brew vs MUD WTR: Which Mushroom Coffee Is Better?

I compare both of my experiences with MUD WTR vs Beyond Brew to see which mushroom coffee is better. Pros, Cons, and comparison section.

GoWellness is reader supported. If you purchase through a link mentioned in this article, we may receive a small commission.

No longer do I spend my mornings drinking a cup of traditional coffee. Instead, I’ve made the switch to a much healthier option. Mushroom coffee has taken the world by storm in recent years, and I think it’s an excellent beverage that provides energy along with a host of other health benefits.

Let’s compare two popular mushroom coffee brands: MUDWTR and Beyond Brew. I’ll tell you all you need to know about both products so you can choose the best one for your mornings. Get ready to learn about what’s in these products, what I liked, what I didn’t like and how much these products will set you back.

Key Facts

Most popular

Key Facts on MUDWTR

  • MUDWTR contains a small amount of caffeine that is much less than a traditional cup of coffee.
  • You won’t experience palpitations, anxiety or an energy crash later in the day when you consume MUDWTR.
  • MUDWTR is made using a blend of functional mushrooms that provide energy, anti-inflammatory benefits, improved focus and so much more.

Choose MUD WTR if…

  • You like the black tea base and its flavor. This product also contains chai.
  • You prefer this brand’s functional mushroom blend that it uses. MUDWTR contains Cordyceps, Reishi, Chaga and Lion’s Mane. Also included is turmeric.

Key Facts on Beyond Brew

  • Beyond Brew offers a burst of energy along with immune and gut support.
  • There is 1/10th the amount of caffeine in Beyond Brew as a traditional cup of coffee.
  • Beyond Brew contains six potent functional mushrooms.

Choose Beyond Brew if...

  • You’re looking for holistic energy from functional mushrooms such as Lion's Mane, Reishi, Chaga, Cordyceps sinensis, Cordyceps militaris and Turkey Tail.
  • You would prefer the cacao flavor that this product has compared to other functional mushroom drinks.

MUDWTR: What Is It?

mushroom coffee mud wtr

When you’re tired of your boring cup of coffee each morning and want to try something that’s much healthier, MUDWTR is an excellent option. Made with natural and organic ingredients like turmeric, chai, cinnamon and functional mushrooms, you can use MUDWTR to feel more energized and focused throughout the day. It contains about 1/7th the amount of caffeine as a regular cup of coffee, so say goodbye to jitters and that awful afternoon energy crash. I love that it doesn’t give me palpitations but rather boosts my immune system and helps me stay focused all day without feeling wired.

Below, you'll see MUD WTR stacked up against other mushroom coffee and similar adaptogen products if you wish to learn more!

My Experience With MUDWTR

I have loved using MUDWTR. I made the switch to this functional mushroom coffee after I realized that my morning cup of coffee wasn’t really making me feel very good. The caffeine was making me feel anxious and jittery. Palpitations became the norm for many hours after. Don’t get me started on the GI issues that coffee causes me.

I was nervous about the flavor of MUDWTR but that turned out to not be an issue. It’s definitely different than regular coffee, but it’s not bad at all. MUDWTR is one of the better options because it contains cacao, cinnamon and chai. Combined, those flavors make for a really nice beverage.

While MUDWTR contains less caffeine than regular coffee, I didn’t feel a major downshift in my energy levels when using this product. The functional mushrooms provided a much healthier surge of energy that lasted much of the day. I felt like I was able to wind down in the evening much easier.

The immune boost and health benefits that this functional mushroom blend provides are superior to drinking coffee, which really doesn’t provide any benefits. I feel like I’ve made a healthier switch for morning energy that actually benefits my body.

What I Liked

  • The flavor is very pleasant.
  • MUDWTR provides much healthier energy that doesn’t result in an energy crash or jitteriness.
  • I noticed an immune boost when using this product.
  • This product is made from organic ingredients.

What I Didn’t Like

  • It’s a bit expensive, but not really if you’re someone who stops at a coffee shop every morning.
  • It takes a little work to blend MUDWTR. However, you can purchase a frother from the company, which makes the process much easier.

Beyond Brew: What Is It?

mushroom coffee beyond brew

Similar to MUDWTR, Beyond Brew contains a blend of functional mushrooms. The blend consists of Lion's Mane, Reishi, Chaga, Cordyceps sinensis, Cordyceps militaris and Turkey Tail. It contains even less caffeine than MUDWTR, at just 1/10th the normal amount. Beyond Brew has a cacao base, and uniquely contains heat-resistant probiotics. You get the gut health benefits from functional mushrooms as well as beneficial bacteria.

My Experience With Beyond Brew

As I briefly mentioned, traditional coffee and caffeine tend to bother my stomach. I tried Beyond Brew because of its functional mushroom blend and decreased caffeine, but I was interested in the probiotics that were added.

The flavor of Beyond Brew wasn’t as good as MUDWTR, but it wasn’t unpleasant. I definitely think some additional ingredients would be beneficial. It blends pretty well and has a smooth texture.

I experienced less energy when using Beyond Brew, but that may be because of the minimal caffeine that it contains. There was also an adjustment period for the probiotics or the other ingredients in general. It’s hard to tell which was the issue.

What I Liked

  • I liked the functional mushrooms that were chosen for Beyond Brew. They’re very potent and powerful.
  • The very minimal amount caffeine is nice if you’re looking to really cut back on your consumption.
  • The value is great, especially if you purchase multiple jars of product.

What I Didn’t Like

  • The flavor wasn’t my favorite.
  • Beyond Brew caused a little bit of GI upset for the first week or so of using it.

Comparison Section of MUDWTR vs. Beyond Brew

Let’s break down how MUDWTR and Beyond Brew really compare to one another.

Comparing Formulas

There are a few differences in the functional mushrooms that these two brands use. Beyond Brew contains a few different ones, including Turkey Tail. Also, there are a few additional ingredients in MUDWTR, such as turmeric, cinnamon and chai. Some of these ingredients contribute to the flavor of the product, but they can also provide some health benefits.

Beyond Brew contains probiotics, which MUDWTR does not.

Comparing Taste, Texture and Mixability

I definitely liked the taste of MUDWTR more. It has a very warm flavor, and you really taste the chai and cinnamon. This was missing from Beyond Brew, which has a much earthier flavor.

Both products mixed about the same. You will benefit from having a frother with most mushroom coffees. Once you get them mixed, the texture is very smooth.

Comparing How They Made Me Feel

I experienced more energy when drinking MUDWTR daily. This could be from the slightly more caffeine that’s in the product or the functional mushrooms that are used.

Beyond Brew required a slight adjustment period in regard to my gut health. That’s likely because of the probiotics that have been added to the formula.

Regardless, neither product made me feel jittery or anxious.

Comparing Price

You can purchase MUDWTR for $60 for a one-time purchase. This is approximately a 30-day supply. The subscription service discounts the price to $40.

Beyond Brew costs $37.99 for a one-time purchase. You can save 25% by purchasing four jars at a time.

What Are The Main Differences Between Beyond Brew and MUDWTR?

The formulas of these two products stand out as one of the main differences between them. Beyond Brew contains more functional mushrooms and probiotics. However, MUDWTR has added a few other ingredients that contribute to the overall taste of their product. Chai and cinnamon might be nice additions to Beyond Brew as well as a way to enhance its flavor.

Final Thoughts

Regardless of which product you choose to try, they’re both much healthier alternatives to regular coffee in the morning. Functional mushrooms can provide so many amazing health benefits. Your morning beverage becomes so much more about energy. It’s about taking care of your body and mind so you feel better overall.

I continue to use MUDWTR as my mushroom coffee of choice. I like the flavor; it helps me feel focused and energized throughout the day and I’ve been able to ditch all of those unpleasant side effects that I was experiencing with regular coffee.

Photo of author

Courtney D'Angelo, MS, RD

Courtney D'Angelo, MS, RD, earned her masters degree in Nutrition and Foods from the University of Georgia. She's a Registered Dietitian at Morrison Healthcare and has a strong passion in helping people improve their wellness!

Leave a Comment