Alloy vs Evernow: Which Menopause HRT Is Better?

It felt like a big challenge to figure out what my body was doing during perimenopause and into menopause. Not to mention, it was hard … Read More

GoWellness is reader supported. If you purchase through a link mentioned in this article, we may receive a small commission.

It felt like a big challenge to figure out what my body was doing during perimenopause and into menopause. Not to mention, it was hard to find relief from the symptoms I was experiencing. Mood swings, hot flashes, night sweats and gut issues were all bringing me down. Then I came across two brands of hormone replacement therapy products that seemed promising. I gave them a try, and I’m here to share my experiences with you.

Let’s talk about Alloy and Evernow.

Key Factors to Know Before Buying Alloy or Evernow

Most popular


  • You can access free ongoing support and care from Alloy when you’re a client.
  • Alloy’s product line includes probiotics, gut health supplements and hormone replacement therapy to provide relief from common menopause symptoms.
  • Alloy is made up of an experienced team of professionals that help you find targeted solutions for your symptoms.


  • Evernow takes the approach of using evidence-based treatments to address specific menopause symptoms.
  • Evernow products are available by mail or by having your prescription sent to your local pharmacy.
  • There are different product types available from Evernow, including pills and patches. The Evernow team will help you figure out what the best option is for your situation.

An Overview the Alloy Menopause Brand

The belief behind Alloy’s creation gave me a lot of peace of mind. When you’re in the middle of these hormonal fluctuations, it can often feel like there’s no hope. However, Alloy believes that all menopause symptoms are treatable. Evidence-based, Alloy initially asks that you complete a three-minute assessment in order to provide you with initial recommendations for products that have the potential to help you. You give feedback on these recommendations, and then you will be paired with an Alloy medical professional who will either approve or amend your selections. It takes approximately three to five days to receive your product if you’re having it shipped to your door.

Types of HRT They Offer

Alloy offers both progesterone and estrogen therapy as part of their treatment program. Many of Alloy’s products that contain progesterone can be used to strengthen the uterus, regulate your menstrual cycle and reduce symptoms that come from these wacky fluctuations in hormones that we women are so prone to.

Alloy uses a natural form of estrogen in some of their products. Estradiol, sourced from yams, is molecularly the same as estrogen that’s already in your body. However, some women need an added boost to help get back on track and feel like themselves again.

My Experience

I came across Alloy on the internet while I was looking for different ideas for treating perimenopause and menopause symptoms. The three-minute survey was really quick, which made me a little apprehensive. Would they gather enough information to really make an appropriate recommendation? I was happy with the products they suggested to me (progesterone administered orally), and I provided my approval. I also chose to connect with one of the staff members at Alloy so I could make sure the best products were being used for my symptoms.

I chose to purchase my progesterone supplement through the mail. While it takes a few more days than if I went to my local pharmacy, it’s just a more convenient option. I didn’t experience any adverse effects from this oral supplement, but I do like that other brands offer a topical progesterone option. That wasn’t available through Alloy.


  • The initial survey is very fast.
  • You can review your recommendations and request changes.
  • You have the option to connect with a professional at Alloy to discuss your recommendations.
  • Products can be sent to your home, or you can pick them up from your local pharmacy.


  • Product selection is a bit limited.
  • I like the idea of speaking with a medical professional before you receive product recommendations.

An Overview of Evernow

Designed to provide a way of accessing menopause care and treatments from the comfort of your home, Evernow’s team consists of medical professionals, scientists and technologists who have a passion for what they do. Not only is this brand geared towards menopause treatments, but also long-term female health. Their products address menopause issues like anxiety, vaginal discomfort, insomnia, pain, hot flashes and night sweats.

Types of HRT They Offer

Evernow is impressive with the number of HRT products that they offer. Some of their options include:

Estradiol Patch

You can get relief from some of your menopause symptoms in as little as two weeks while using the Evernow Estradiol patch. Because it’s topical, there are minimal side effects.

Estradiol Pill

If you’d prefer to take your estrogen in pill form, Evernow offers this as well. Some people have sensitive skin, which makes it easier to take an oral supplement.

Estrogen-Based Vaginal Cream

If you’re experiencing symptoms that are related to your vaginal health, Evernow has an estrogen-based vaginal cream that can help alleviate dryness, irritation, pain during sex and recurring urinary tract infections.

My Experience

I like that Evernow has a few different types of products available if you’re not simply looking for an oral prescription. I opted to try their vaginal estradiol cream. It worked really well for symptoms like dryness from an interior standpoint. However, it was a bit irritating after using it for a number of consecutive days.

Evernow recommends that you don’t have sexual intercourse for eight hours after you use this cream, so it involves a little planning ahead. That’s one thing I didn’t love about it.


  • The Evernow team assesses all of the information that you provide before you decide what products are ideal for your situation.
  • Certain FSA and HSA accounts will cover the cost of Evernow items.
  • Evernow has a pretty impressive backing of medical professionals and experienced individuals.
  • If you’re dealing with specific symptoms, like hair loss, there are certain products you can use for that purpose alone.


  • I’d love to see a little more product transparency on the Evernow website.

Comparison Section

While they may seem similar in a lot of ways, let’s compare Alloy and Evernow to see which one is the better option.

Comparing HRT

Both Alloy and Evernow offer traditional HRT options that focus on using progesterone and estrogen for relief. However, I feel like Evernow provides women with a few extra options. That being said, I do like that Alloy uses a natural form of estradiol, and their products are very safe.

Comparing Pricing

Pricing varies depending on what products you want to try. Just as an example, an oral estradiol supplement from Alloy costs $39.99 per month. You can purchase Evernow’s estradiol pill for as little as $20 per month. There is a membership fee that is billed separately, though.

Main Differences Between Evernow and Alloy

The process of obtaining your HRT is a little different when you’re considering Evernow versus Alloy. Alloy starts the process off with a three-minute assessment. Then you receive your recommendations via email. You have the option to speak with someone on their team, but it’s not a requirement. I like that Evernow provides you with a little more guidance before you make your selections. For me, I really wanted to make sure that I was going to be using something that was effective but also safe.

Which Menopause HRT Is Better: Evernow or Alloy?

Both Alloy and Evernow are excellent options if you’re looking for convenient hormone replacement therapy for menopause-related symptoms. If you’re looking for a fast process that puts HRT into your hands within a few days, Alloy may be the better option for you. I’m happy to wait a little longer to make sure I’m starting the right treatment. In this case, Evernow is my favorite.

My Recommendations

I think it’s important for women to take their time when considering hormone replacement therapy for their menopause symptoms. Most women experience more than one or two symptoms during this transitional phase, which is why it can be challenging to find the right treatment option. If you have the opportunity, speak with someone from Alloy, Evernow or a different HRT provider. Let them know what your symptoms are, what your concerns are and what you’re hoping to get out of your treatment plan.

Alloy and Evernow are two very good brands that can help you get back to feeling like yourself.



  • You want to streamline the process of obtaining HRT.
  • You want the option of picking up your prescription from a pharmacy that is local to you.
  • You like the product options available at Alloy.


  • You would like a more personalized approach to HRT.
  • Your FSA or HSA account covers these products.
  • You think that your symptoms are one of the many that Evernow can treat.
Photo of author

Courtney D'Angelo, MS, RD

Courtney D'Angelo, MS, RD, earned her masters degree in Nutrition and Foods from the University of Georgia. She's a Registered Dietitian at Morrison Healthcare and has a strong passion in helping people improve their wellness!

Leave a Comment